Championship Vinyl, The Inner Workings Of

The inimitable Hipinion is running a challenge at the moment to list your top five songs from your top five artists of all time. Piece of cake, I thought. Wrong. I had enough trouble coming up with my five favorite bands, much less singling out five songs in their catalogs. But I’ve got a list now. I want my efforts to come to something, so I’ve decided to post it here. Feel free to post your own list. Here’s mine:

Yo La Tengo
1. Today is the Day (fast version)
2. Detouring America With Horns
3. Drug Test
4. The Lie and How We Told It
5. You Can Have it All

Destroyer
1. Beggars Might Ride
2. The Bad Arts
3. It’s Gonna Take an Airplane
4. Self Portrait With Thing (Tonight is Not Your Night)
5. Mercy [We Had the Right]

Wilco
1. I’m Always in Love
2. Muzzle of Bees
3. At Least That’s What You Said
4. When You Wake Up Feeling Old
5. Pot Kettle Black

Mountain Goats
1. Game Shows Touch Our Lives
2. Jaipur
3. Song for the Julian Calendar
4. Tallahassee
5. Grendel’s Mother

The Replacements
1. Androgynous
2. Alex Chilton
3. Answering Machine
4. Can’t Hardly Wait (Tim version)
5. Left of the Dial

So there it is. Looking over it, I’ve picked five fairly canonical indie bands, nothing unique about that aspect of the list at all. Destroyer is probably the only unique touch in there. I like to think that I got some pretty deep cuts within the artist lists though, check out that unreleased Replacements studio outtake, or the super-early Mountain Goats and Yo La Tengo tracks.

The Replacements list was unbelievably easy; they’re not the most consistent band out there, so the hits just stand out like a sore thumb. I had a really tough time with Yo La Tengo and The Mountain Goats, mostly because I feel YLT is a better albums-band than a singles-band, and The Mountain Goats just have a such a vast and uniform discography, much of which I still haven’t heard.

I’m surprised that I’ve finally admitted that Pavement has fallen off my radar. They’d been my favorite band since…10th grade or so? I think my embarassing love for them culminated in my painting of the Wowee Zowee cover art on my senior square. I haven’t looked at that thing since I graduated. So yeah, it’s been a good ride Pavement, thanks for all the good stuff, but it’s time for me to move on. It’s not you, it’s me. I’m the one who hasn’t worked hard enough in this relationship; I wasn’t able to give enough of a commitment, and that’s all my fault. But we can still be friends, right? Malkmus?

Top 5 links of the past few days:

Advertisements

3 responses to “Championship Vinyl, The Inner Workings Of

  1. Ok I think I’m going to go for the top five songs from top 5 artists, but I don’t think these are in any particular order:

    The Pixies
    ————
    1. River Euphrates
    2. Where Is My Mind
    3. Debaser
    4. Something Against You
    5. Caribou

    The Mountain Goats
    ——————-
    1. Bluejays and Cardinals
    2. Island Garden Song
    3. Going to Lebanon
    4. Quetzalcoatl Is Born
    5. (don’t really know) Dinu Lapati’s Bones

    Ted Leo
    ———
    1. Under the Hedge
    2. Gold Finch and the Red Oak Tree
    3. The Crane Takes Flight
    4. Tell Balgeary, Balgury Is Dead
    5. Walking To Do

    The Books
    ———-
    1. Read, Eat, Sleep
    2. There Is No There
    3. Smells Like Content
    4. All your Base Are Belong To Them
    5. That Right A’int Shit
    or alternatively An Animated Description of Mr. Maps

    (really a toss up)
    Devendra Banhart
    —————-
    1. At the Hop
    2. When They Come
    3. This Is The Way
    4. Insect Eyes
    5. Little Boys
    or alternatively Tit Smoking in the Temple of Artisan Mimcry
    or even Rejoicing in the Hands

    I really should have put much more though into this, but it was a fun, late-night thought-provoker.

  2. Sam, I have to say that I found it hilarious that you listed Going to Lebanon as a favorite song of yours. Oh, the irony. You’ve been playing it all summer, haven’t you.

  3. gosh I just knew someone would say something….yes….yes….

    screw islamofacists for denying me music.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s